Search :
Tuesday, 09 February 2010 - 24 Safar 1431 H
ISLAM Google’s abuse of power to take over popular YoutubeIslam.com
By Faraz Omar
Google has sent shockwaves in the online Muslim community by wrestling to take over the popular Islamic video sharing website YoutubeIslam.com. The website run for over three-and-a-half years by Sheikh Yusuf Estes, a popular da’ee in America, is 100 percent child safe and visited by thousands of net surfers for videos on a variety of subjects.
“Our little website became very popular with even non-Muslims. Everywhere we go people tell us how much they appreciate having something of this high moral value, excellent quality and professional approach to presenting Islam,” said Yusuf Estes.
The Sheikh says Google, the owner of YouTube.com, is trying to scare people into giving them their website domain names if they contain anything with the sound or appearance of the words like “tube”, “you”, “youtoo”, “youtube”, “tubeyou” or even words like “tub”, if connected in some way with anything like “U”.
Since earlier this year, Google’s law firm has been trying to take ownership of YoutubeIslam.com.
“Will we just hand over a million dollar website for free?” questions Yusuf.
“First they said our logo and images were identical to theirs, which was a big lie. Then they changed their direction and called us up on the phone saying we should give them the domain because they are Google, the biggest and most powerful company on the Internet and they can make it difficult for anyone who gets in their way.
“Then they came up with the idea that our domain name sounded too much like theirs and it was confusing people who use the Internet. For that reason, went to the controllers of the Internet itself with their claim and requested what is called arbitration.”
But Sheikh Yusuf Estes says his website’s name cannot be mistaken for Google’s. “Does anyone really have trouble making a distinction between the word ‘youtube’ and ‘youtubeislam’?”
“The fact is, Google got sued for exactly what they claim we are doing, but in their case there really was no difference in the sound. When they bought YouTube for $1.3 billion, the company UTUBE.com sued them as they owned that name on the Internet for 10 years before Google did,” he added.
What Sheikh Yusuf is worried about is the possibility that Google may misuse the website by advertising Haraam things and using it for un-Islamic purposes.
He calls on every Internet user to support his campaign by spreading the message and speaking up against the takeover, as time is running out.
“Without notification in advance, our server, Godaddy.com, sent an email stating due to a decision made by arbitration on the Internet, they are going to give our domain name to Google,” he said. – SG
“Our little website became very popular with even non-Muslims. Everywhere we go people tell us how much they appreciate having something of this high moral value, excellent quality and professional approach to presenting Islam,” said Yusuf Estes.
The Sheikh says Google, the owner of YouTube.com, is trying to scare people into giving them their website domain names if they contain anything with the sound or appearance of the words like “tube”, “you”, “youtoo”, “youtube”, “tubeyou” or even words like “tub”, if connected in some way with anything like “U”.
Since earlier this year, Google’s law firm has been trying to take ownership of YoutubeIslam.com.
“Will we just hand over a million dollar website for free?” questions Yusuf.
“First they said our logo and images were identical to theirs, which was a big lie. Then they changed their direction and called us up on the phone saying we should give them the domain because they are Google, the biggest and most powerful company on the Internet and they can make it difficult for anyone who gets in their way.
“Then they came up with the idea that our domain name sounded too much like theirs and it was confusing people who use the Internet. For that reason, went to the controllers of the Internet itself with their claim and requested what is called arbitration.”
But Sheikh Yusuf Estes says his website’s name cannot be mistaken for Google’s. “Does anyone really have trouble making a distinction between the word ‘youtube’ and ‘youtubeislam’?”
“The fact is, Google got sued for exactly what they claim we are doing, but in their case there really was no difference in the sound. When they bought YouTube for $1.3 billion, the company UTUBE.com sued them as they owned that name on the Internet for 10 years before Google did,” he added.
What Sheikh Yusuf is worried about is the possibility that Google may misuse the website by advertising Haraam things and using it for un-Islamic purposes.
He calls on every Internet user to support his campaign by spreading the message and speaking up against the takeover, as time is running out.
“Without notification in advance, our server, Godaddy.com, sent an email stating due to a decision made by arbitration on the Internet, they are going to give our domain name to Google,” he said. – SG
OTHER NEWS FROM Islam
14 Comments have been posted. Post Your Comments
» Change the domain name | Shafeeq V posted...
Why not change the domain name to something not similar from youtube. Is it really that hard? The truth is, the owner of youtubeislam is just using the term youtube for his own selfishness without regard to trademark laws in the US. So instead of making this issue big, why not change the name to something else?
» Loveable Old Sheikh | Yusuf Estes posted... Bismillah - Salam alaykum peace to all:
I love the way Muslims pull together in times like these. But we need to be fair, always.
Let Google have a chance to say their side of this story too.
This issue does effect Muslims everywhere, but we must always remember to give everyone their "rights" - even our enemies have rights too.
So be sure to contact them for their "side of this story".
Let's stay balanced and remain fair, even when others do not.
Allah is the One to give success, ameen.
» Allah with you | famillyelhilali posted... I love the way Muslims pull together in times like these. But we need to be fair, always.
Let Google have a chance to say their side of this story too.
This issue does effect Muslims everywhere, but we must always remember to give everyone their "rights" - even our enemies have rights too.
So be sure to contact them for their "side of this story".
Let's stay balanced and remain fair, even when others do not.
Allah is the One to give success, ameen.
InshaAllah you will be aided...
We make "douaa" for you and all muslemeen...
Allah protect you and help you.Amen
» One of the many WAKE UP calls to Muslims. | SlaveofAllah posted... We make "douaa" for you and all muslemeen...
Allah protect you and help you.Amen
Bismillah - Aselamu Aleykum to all.
May Allah give us the right guidance, knowledge & patience. May Allah protect and reward you with countless HASANAT Shaiek Yusuf. Ameen! It is nothing but one type of CALL to believers to WAKE from IGNORANCE, defend their rights while giving other's right aswell as Loveable Old Sheikh said. Woe to Muslims, if we defend our DEEN it's our HONOR + for our own benefit, if not Allah will replace us with others who will bring the RIGHT ISLAM back to rule the world!
» Re: Change the domain name | Shafeeq V | SlaveofAllah posted... I was bothered by what you said "his own selfishness". Who do you think you are to say that? You think you are smart enough to know about changing domain and trademark laws? FYI he owns many other domains. I hope you first learn what is respect and wisdom before you post any comment online or say a word to others. Re-read at how and what Loveable Old Sheikh posted. May Allah brings the time of disappearance of IGNORANCE. Ameen!
» Please respect the law | Mohammed S posted... Assalam-o-alaikum. May Allah's mercy be upon us all. Ameen. After reading this article, I was disappointed and angered that this is even taking place. Youtube.com is a registered and copyrighted name, and it is against the law to use this name, even if it is appending Islam to it. You don't see FacebookIslam.com or MyspaceIslam.com or MicrosoftIslam.com or BMWIslam.com or TwitterIslam.com etc for a reason. It is against the law. Allah is watching you, please do not break laws!! Astagfirullah!!
» May Allah give you Istaqamat | Mubasher posted... That is their old tactics, choose the easy way, Allah will help you.
» May almighty help the sufferer | SMSM posted... I do not have the language to say about what google is doing. May Allah help us in patience. When I was young, I thought that being a good person and going to Jannah is easy. But, now I do understand, how it takes to make yourself balanced. Now a days, becoming bad seems more praiseworthy than a good person. May Allah help us with wisdom, word and all means of good to strugle against all sort of evils. Ameen.
» Shafeeq V | Qaiyum posted... Dear Shafeeq Please read this again---> the owner of YouTube.com, is trying to scare people into giving them their website domain names if they contain anything with the sound or appearance of the words like “tube”, “you”, “youtoo”, “youtube”, “tubeyou” or even words like “tub”, if connected in some way with anything like “U”.
&
Does anyone really have trouble making a distinction between the word ‘youtube’ and ‘youtubeislam’?”
Jazaak Allah
» Californian resident | San Francisco posted... &
Does anyone really have trouble making a distinction between the word ‘youtube’ and ‘youtubeislam’?”
Jazaak Allah
"The truth is, the owner of youtubeislam is just using the term youtube for his own selfishness without regard to trademark laws in the US." Do you think Google would be trying to steal a domain named youtube123.com if it had only two or three hits a month? This is not about trademark laws, its about protecting the 'Islam' in youtubeislam.com
» May Allah chose the best | Omer posted... I'm not aware of the trademark laws in the US so i didn't wish to make any comment on that. We must know about the matter(trademark laws in US) before calling anyone selfish. As far as my knowledge about Sheikh Yusuf Estes is concerned, I regard him as a Muslim who is trying the best of his abilities to spread the message of Islam in a very peaceful manner. May Allah tala gave him success in both worlds. Aameen.
» It is also fault of godaddy.com | khalid posted... I have hundereds of domains registered with godaddy and i feel the support rendered by godaddy without seeking explanation from youtubeislam administrators, blindly sending information about transferring domain to google is shocking and I feel to show my protest to google, I need to transfer my domains to some other service providers..
» | Muslimah posted... It's sad to think that through the Sheikh's hard effort to provide knowledge of Islam to others that it's going down the drain so quickly like this. I pray and beg Allah ta'ala to make it easy on him and make this right and bring the evil-doers to justice. The Word of Islam needs to be put out there- why aren't you supporting him more?? Aren't us Muslims supposed to be working together?! Support Sheik Yusuf, not Google!
Allah guide us all, Ameen
» | IMCurtain posted... Allah guide us all, Ameen
GoDaddy afraid of Google, what a shame. Promote your blog with us, http://www.imcurtain.com

RSS Feeds